In our shoppe daily

We have an assortment of cookies, cupcakes, cake balls, cake pops, bars, celebration cakes, hot coffee and tea!

check out our instagram feed for our daily flavors @thecakeryfishkill

Grab and Go pricing

Cupcakes - $4.00 each - one dozen $40

CUPCAKE FLAVORS AVAILABLE DAILY: VANILLA CAKE WITH VANILLA BUTTERCREAM, VANILLA CAKE WITH CHOCOLATE BUTTERCREAM, CHOCOLATE CAKE WITH CHOCOLATE BUTTERCREAM, CHOCOLATE CAKE WITH VANILLA BUTTERCREAM, CARROT CAKE WITH CREAM CHEESE AND WALNUTS, RED VELVET CAKE WITH CREAM CHEESE, COOKIE MONSTER, SALTED CARAMEL, CANNOLI, STRAWBERRY CRUNCH, TIRAMISU AND BROWNIE CAKE BATTER. PLUS! 6 BAKER’S CHOICE FLAVORS MONTHLY!

OCTOBER 2025 MONTHLY

SNICKERS ~ Vanilla cake filled with a gooey caramel and peanut filling, topped with peanut butter frosting and finished with ganache, caramel drizzle and peanuts

M&M COOKIE ~ Chocolate chip confetti mixed cake with ganache filling, vanilla buttercream and topped with a mini M&M chocolate chip cookie.

HALLOWEEN DIRT ~ Chocolate cake with cookies and cream filling, chocolate buttercream topping rolled in oreo crumbs and finished with gummy worms.

POISON APPLE ~ Cinnamon filled with a caramel apple filling, topped with a green apple flavored frosting and decorated to look like an eyeball.

ALMOND JOY ~ Almond cake filled with ganache with coconut buttercream, rolled in coconut, drizzled with ganache and Topped with almonds.

“AIR HEAD” ~ Vanilla cake filled raspberry jam and decorated with pink Cotton candy buttercream to look like brains.

Assorted JUMBO cookies -$3.50 each

cake balls - $3 each - one dozen $30

cake pops - $4 each - one dozen $42

decorated sugar cookies (prices marked in store)

Assorted bars, Macarons and MAcaroons - $4.50 each - ONE DOZEN $48

Celebration cakes - 4” $25+ - 6” $50+

Custom Cake Pricing and Inquiries

Every custom cake is individually priced.

To develop a quote for your custom cake you will need to know the number of servings to begin.

For reference, Buttercream Cakes start at $7.00 per serving and Fondant Cakes start at $9.00 per serving.

Sculpted cakes, figures, flowers, additional flavors/fillings and decorating time are all additional.

Labor Charges are $40/hour and are based upon intricacy of the design.

A minimum of 2 weeks advance notice is requested to place a custom order.

Click the link below to submit an inquiry for a quote, THIS INQUIRY DOES NOT GUARANTEE OR CONFIRM A CUSTOM ORDER.

A 30% non-refundable deposit is required to confirm an order.

Custom Cake Inquiry

Cupcake Flavors

Basic Flavors: Vanilla, Vanilla Chocolate, Chocolate, Chocolate Vanilla

Gourmet Flavors: Almond Joy, Apple Pie Cheesecake, Blackberry Cheesecake, Blueberry, Blueberry Cheesecake, Caramel Cinnamon French Toast, Caramel Latte, Caramel Pecan Turtle, Carrot, Chocolate Pecan Pie, Chocolate Bacon, Chocolate Caramel Pretzel, Chocolate Caramel Apple, Chocolate Chip, Chocolate Chip Coconut, Chocolate Espresso, Chocolate Lovers Dream, Chocolate Mocha, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Chocolate Peppermint, Chocolate Raspberry, Chocolate Raspberry Cheesecake, Coconut Mango, Coffee Overload, Confetti, Cookie Dough'nt You Want Some, Cookies and Cream, Cranberry Orange, Cream Cheese Cinnamon Bun, Dulce De Leche, Egg Nog, Elvis, Grasshopper, Holy Cannoli, Hot Chocolate, Hot Fudge Sundae, Hudson Valley Apple Pie, Lemon Blueberry, Lemon Blueberry Cornbread, Lemon Raspberry, Mango Kiwi, Maple Bacon, Maple Walnut, Mixed Berry Cheesecake, Molasses Spice, Nutella Cream Cheese Pumpkin, Nutella Explosion, Peanut Butter and Jelly, Pina Colada, Pumpkin, Pumpkin Chocolate Chip, Pumpkin spiced Latte, Rainbow, Raspberry, Raspberry Cheesecake, Red Velvet, Rocky Road, RootBeer Float, Salted Caramel, Smores, Snickerbomb, Spiced Butterscotch, Strawberry Champagne, Strawberry Cheesecake, Strawberry Kiwi, Strawberry Lemonade, Take5, The Scherhaufer, Toasted Almond, Triple Chocolate, Vanilla Caramel Latte, White Chocolate Cranberry Almond, White Chocolate Pumpkin.

Adult Flavors*: Chocolate Red Wine, Irish Car Bomb, Kahlua Mudslide, Spiked Egg Nog, Tequila Lime, Tipsy Gingerbread, Vanilla Caramel Bourbon, White Wine White Chocolate Raspberry *[+$]

Cake Pop & Cake Ball Flavors

Vanilla, Birthday Cake, Chocolate, Red Velvet, Peanut Butter Chocolate, Oreo, Cannoli, Salted Caramel, Smores, Strawberry, Lemon, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Cookie Dough, Blueberry, Almond Amaretto, Snickerdoodle, Chocolate Strawberry

Seasonal Flavors: Hot Chocolate, Gingerbread, Peppermint Chocolate, Pumpkin

Cake Flavors

Basic: Vanilla, Chocolate, Marble, Funfetti

Premium: Almond, Blueberry, Carrot, Chocolate, Chocolate Chip (Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Chips), Cinnamon, Coconut, Coffee/Espresso, Funfetti (Vanilla Cake with Rainbow Sprinkles), Lemon, Marble, Oreo (Vanilla Cake with Oreo Crumble), Pistachio, Pumpkin *Seasonally available September - November, Red Velvet, Strawberry, Vanilla *Multi-Colored/Rainbow* (*will be an up-charge)

Filling Flavors

Basic: Vanilla Custard, Chocolate Custard, Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Cookies & Cream Buttercream, Raspberry Buttercream, Strawberry Buttercream, Caramel Buttercream, Cinnamon Buttercream, Almond Buttercream, or generally any other flavor buttercream!

Premium:
Almond Buttercream, Apple Compote, Bailey’s Buttercream, Bailey’s Mousse, Blueberry Buttercream, Blueberry Compote, Cannoli Cream, Cheesecake +$, Chocolate Ganache, Chocolate Mousse, Coconut Mousse, Coffee/Espresso Mousse, Cookie Butter Mousse, Cream Cheese Icing, Edible Cookie Dough +$, Lemon Curd, Nutella Mousse, Oreo Ganache, Peanut Butter Mousse, Pistachio Mousse, Raspberry Jam, Raspberry Mousse, Salted Caramel Swirl, Strawberries – Fresh Sliced, Strawberry Jam, Strawberry Mousse, Vanilla Mousse, Whiskey Ganache, White Chocolate Buttercream, White Chocolate Ganache, White Chocolate Mousse

cake Coverings

Basic: Naked*, Vanilla Buttercream, Chocolate Buttercream, Cookies & Cream Buttercream, Raspberry Buttercream, Strawberry Buttercream, Caramel Buttercream, Cinnamon Buttercream, Almond Buttercream, Lemon Buttercream,

Premium: Chocolate Ganache, Fondant, Whipped Cream**

*Naked means a thin layer of buttercream that reveals the cake layers through it.

**There are limitations to design with a whipped cream covering. Cakes with a whipped cream covering will still be crumb coated in buttercream for stability.

staff picks:

Katie p-mac-g’s Chocolate Chip Cheese-cake

Chocolate Chip Cake with Cookie Dough and Cream Cheese Buttercream Swirl Filling, Covered in Chocolate Buttercream, Chocolate Drip and Chocolate Chips

Kelsey’s Nutella S’Mores cake

Chocolate Cake with Graham Cracker Buttercream Swirled with Nutella Covered in Toasted Marshmallow Buttercream, Topped with a chocolate drip and all The S’Mores fixin’s

Ashley’s Cookie Butter dream cake

White Cake with Cookie Butter Mousse swirled with Cookie Butter Filling, Covered in Cookie Butter Buttercream, Topped with a Cookie Butter Drip and Crushed Biscoff Cookies

OTHER POPULAR combinations:

Birthday cake

Funfetti Cake with Birthday Cake Buttercream Filling Covered with Vanilla Buttercream and Rainbow Sprinkles Topped with Colorful Candies

black and white

MARBLE CAKE WITH WHITE CHOCOLATE GANACHE FILLING, COVERED IN CHOCOLATE BUTTERCREAM TOPPED WITH A CHOCOLATE DRIP, AND WHITE AND DARK CHOCOLATE COINS

blueberry lemon

Blueberry Cake with Lemon Curd Filling Covered with Lemon and Blueberry Striped Buttercream Topped with Fresh Blueberries, and Lemon Zest

Cannoli Cake

almond Cake with Cannoli Cream Filling Covered in Cinnamon Buttercream topped with a Chocolate Drip and Cannoli Pieces

CARROT CAKE

Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Filling Covered in Thin Lined 50/50 Cream Cheese/Vanilla Buttercream topped with Buttercream Carrots and Walnuts* (*Optional)

Chocolate lovers dream

Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Mousse swirled with Chocolate Ganache Filling Covered in Chocolate Buttercream Topped with a Chocolate Drip and Chocolate Candy Decorations

chocolate raspberry

Chocolate Cake with Raspberry Jam Filling Covered in Raspberry Buttercream Topped with a Chocolate Drip

COCONUT RASPBERRY CONFECTION CAKE

COCONUT CAKE WITH RASPBERRY JAM FILLING, COVERED IN COCONUT BUTTERCREAM AND PINK PALETTE KNIFE FLOWERS

COFFEE ALMOND FUDGE

Almond Cake with Chocolate Ganache Filling Covered in Espresso Buttercream Topped with Chocolate Drip, chocolate covered espresso beans and Sliced Almonds

Cookie monster

Chocolate chip cake filled with cookie dough buttercream with oreo cookie pieces covered in oreo buttercream and topped with a chocolate drip and chopped cookie pieces

cookie dough

Chocolate Chip Cake with Cookie Dough Buttercream Filling Covered in Vanilla Buttercream Topped with a Chocolate Drip and Edible Cookie Dough Bites

cookies and cream

Chocolate Cake with Marshmallow Buttercream Swirled with Chocolate Ganache and Chunks of Oreo Cookies Covered in Cookies and Cream Buttercream Topped with A Chocolate Drip, Oreo Crumbs and Oreo Cookies

Lemon cake

Lemon cake with a lemon curd filling covered in a thin lined 50/50 Cream cheese/Buttercream topped with fluffy border, yellow sprinkles and lemon zest

mocha choka latté

Espresso Cake with Coffee Mousse swirled with Chocolate Ganache Filling Covered in rich Mocha Buttercream Topped with A chocolate drip, fluffy Mocha Buttercream and Chocolate Covered Espresso Beans

molly brown

Chocolate Cake With Fresh Banana Slices, and Fresh Sliced Strawberries over Vanilla Mousse, Covered in Fresh Whipped Cream Topped with Fresh Strawberries

Peanut Butter explosion

Chocolate Cake with peanut butter mousse swirled with chocolate ganache, covered in peanut butter buttercream, topped with a chocolate drip, and peanut butter cup pieces

“Rainbow cookie” cake

Almond Cake with Swirled Raspberry Jam and Chocolate Ganache Filling Covered with Chocolate Buttercream Topped with a Chocolate Drip and Rainbow Cookie Pieces

RASPBERRY PISTACHIO CAKE

PISTACHIO CAKE WITH RASPBERRY JAM FILLING, COVERED IN STRIPED RASPBERRY AND PISTACHIO BUTTERCREAM TOPPED WITH A CHOCOLATE DRIP AND PISTACHIOS

red velvet cake

Red Velvet Cake with Cream Cheese Buttercream Filling Covered in Thin Lined 50/50 Cream Cheese/Vanilla Buttercream Topped with Red Velvet Cake Crumbs

SALTED CARAMEL CAKE

WHITE CAKE WITH CARAMEL SWIRL BUTTERCREAM FILLING, COVERED IN SALTED CARAMEL BUTTERCREAM, TOPPED WITH A SALTED CARAMEL DRIP

strawberries and cream

Strawberry Cake with Vanilla Mousse and Strawberry Crunch Filling Covered in Strawberry Buttercream and Strawberry Crunch with a Fluffy White Buttercream Border

strawberry shortcake

White Cake with Vanilla Mousse and Fresh Sliced Strawberry Filling Covered in Fresh Whipped cream Topped with Fresh Strawberries

“tiramisu” cake

Coffee Soaked Espresso Cake with Vanilla Custard Filling Covered in Vanilla Buttercream and Dusted With Cocoa Powder

French Macaron Filling

UNLESS A BUTTERCREAM IS CHOSEN, ALL FILLINGS REQUIRE A BUTTERCREAM RIM ALONG THE EDGE OF THE COOKIE TO CREATE A BARRIER FOR YOUR FILLING IN THE CENTER, SO WHEN SANDWICHED TOGETHER THEY DO NOT OVERFLOW OR LEAK

IF YOU WOULD LIKE A PARTICULAR FLAVOR OF BUTTERCREAM PLEASE SPECIFY, OTHERWISE STANDARD VANILLA WILL BE USED

Vanilla Custard, Chocolate Custard, Chocolate Mousse, White Chocolate Mousse, Peanut Butter Mousse, Coconut Mousse, Raspberry Mousse, Cannoli Cream, Cream Cheese Icing, Chocolate Ganache, White Chocolate Ganache, White Chocolate Icing, Raspberry Preserves (seedless), Lemon Curd, Strawberry Preserves, ANY flavor buttercream

Dessert Bar Options

Package One $496 (Serves 64)

4 Dozen mini cupcakes (up to 4 flavors, 2 recommended)

4 Dozen Cake Ball Bites (up to 4 flavors, 2 recommended)

4 Dozen Mini Sugar Cookies

4 Dozen Brownies

(No Substitutions)

Package Two $940 (Serves 128)

4 Dozen mini cupcakes (up to 4 flavors, 2 recommended)

4 Dozen Cake Ball Bites (up to 4 flavors, 2 recommended)

4 Dozen Mini Sugar Cookies

4 Dozen Brownies

4 Dozen Assorted Cookies

4 Dozen Pecan Square Bites

4 Dozen Coconut Macaroons (Gluten Free)

4 Dozen Peanut Butter Chocolate Bars (Gluten Free)

(No substitutions)

A La Carte

$HALF SIZE / $FULL SIZE PER DOZEN

Mini Cheesecakes - $48 per dozen

Cake Pops - $42 per dozen*

Cake Ball Bites - $30 per dozen*

Pecan Square Bites - $28 / $48 per dozen

Mini Cupcakes - $28 per dozen*

Assorted Chip Cookies - $28 / $42 per dozen*

Lemon Bar Bites - $28 / $48 per dozen

French Macarons - $48 per dozen* (Gluten Free)

Regular Cupcakes - $46 per dozen*

Apple Pie Bites - $42 per dozen

Cream Puffs - $48 per dozen

Sugar Cookies - $ vary per dozen

Brownies - $28 / $48 per dozen

Chocolate Dipped Strawberries (Gluten Free) - $36 per dozen

Peanut Butter Chocolate Bar Bites (Gluten Free) - $28 / $48 per dozen

Coconut Macaroons (Gluten Free) - $28 / $48 per dozen

*1 Flavor per dozen

Updated May 2024